“Water for Elephants” relies heavily on the dazzling performances of circus artists to captivate its audience.
Director Jessica Stone skillfully weaves in acrobatic displays that steal the show, creating moments of awe and amazement. The narrative and songs become secondary to the mesmerizing acts unfolding on stage.
A subplot unfolds through flashbacks, involving a circus employee (Gregg Edelman), a leading lady (Isabelle McCalla), and a cunning circus owner (Paul Alexander Nolan). Amidst it all, Grant Gustin shines as the young Mr. Jankowski, while McCalla exudes charisma in her role.
While Stone’s direction impresses with various tricks, the true highlight is the elephant that becomes the heart of the show. Puppet designers create a lovable elephant, though some may find it a bit too cute for the production.
Similar to a three-ring circus, “Water for Elephants” presents a diverse cast of characters, each with their own unique talents. Joe De Paul and Sara Gettelfinger stand out with their performances, adding depth to the overall spectacle.
Paul Alexander Nolan excels in his role as the villainous ringmaster, providing the necessary tension and excitement to the narrative. His absence from Tony nominations is a surprise, given his stellar performance.
Despite some shortcomings in the music by Pigpen Theatre Co., “Water for Elephants” succeeds in delivering a captivating circus experience. Stone’s direction ensures that the audience is treated to unforgettable moments of wonder and entertainment.
Ultimately, “Water for Elephants” celebrates the art of distraction in the world of entertainment, reminding audiences of the joy found in escapism.
“Water for Elephants,” nominated for Best Musical, is currently playing at the Imperial Theatre in New York.
Bruce Miller is editor of the Sioux City Journal.
